Originally Posted by Afro Samurai
Let me be the first to say...
NASH IS OVERRATED!
D'Antoni Scheme anyone? I mean Nash is a very good basketball player, and a very good point guard I mean I like the guy.. but lets be real, who wouldnt be good playing behind Jason Kidd and Kevin Johnson? and who wouldnt put up #s in a fastbreak team run'd but Dantoni? he is a victim of that scheme, hes still a damn good player but I just dont have the heart to rank him over Jason Kidd, who is a better all-around PG.. Nash is the better passer no question but he runs in the friendlier scheme.. Jason Kidd on the other hand is much better on the defensive side of the ball, where Nash is extremely vulnerable. Hes a much better rebounder, and that does matter.. and IMO.. Jason Kidd has the better jumpshot! hes the much better 3-ball shooter, and he hasnt skipped a beat in leadership.. of course as the years go on, the closer Nash gets to outranking him.. but I dont see it yet.
3. BARON DAVIS
4. Billups - the best defending PG
5. Deron Williams
While I agree that Kidd has all around better skills than Nash I can't believe you are saying he's a better 3 point shooter than Nash or even a better jump shooter.