I would disagree with whoever puts Randy in their top 5 hws. He beat Tim and Gonzaga. If AA is top 5, and Tim beat him twice, even though Randy beat Tim, I would rank Tim above Randy. He has had a more consistent run at HW and IMO beat more quality HWs.
I would also take Tim in a rematch over Randy.
Favorite quote of UFC 87.
"These guys both have hearts the size of Tito's fucking head!!" Dana White.