This is a tough one to call. Edgar's made me a believer after the fights with BJ Penn and the war he had with Maynard.
Both have great speed. Melendez has the better power...but after seeing the shot Maynard gave him in the first round and the way he showed heart, I'm going with Edgar by UD. Either way, its a tough one to call and a very good argument could be made for both fighters. I'd love to see this one actually happen.
Chuck Liddell|BJ Penn|Lyoto Machida|Kid Yamamoto|Urijah Faber|Dan Henderson|Daniel Cormier|Ronda Rousey|Pat Barry|Anthony Pettis