Originally Posted by Masscore
I like Rodgers but Top 5 GOAT is a stretch. He has had a great career so far but to say he is up there with guys like Marino, Elway, Montana, Unitas, Tarkenton, Farve and so on, is just too early.
Even in his own "era" I would only rank him 4th right now.
No way would I put him top 5 of all time right now. What I said was...
He'll be top 5 GOAT when he's done.