I do indeed remember that.
I am more of an agnostic in this situation, rather than choosing between sides, I will say that the previous fight no longer matters. We do not know who was more injured or who was the furthest from their potential at that particular point in time.
Come Saturday when we find out who is the UFC Heavyweight champion in the present rather than the past. Who won the Battle of the One-Legged Men will be irrelevant and redundant.