Originally Posted by noahm
This would be the same as giving Matt Serra an immediate rematch after 2nd the GSP fight. He "destroyed" GSP in the first just like JDS "destroyed" Cain, then got manhandled in the second. Makes perfect sense to me.
Both pairs of fights played out pretty similarly, yet nobody was comparing them as anything close in level of destruction the way they are the two JDS/Cain fights. JDS got utterly dominated....no rubbermatch...sorry.
Not really... Serra was a huge upset and he got the shot by winning the comeback edition of TUF. JDS earned his by beating all the top contenders on the way to a shot.
I agree he shouldn't get an immediate rematch though.