PDA

View Full Version : Carwin vs. Overeem.



Bloodbeard
04-10-2010, 07:11 PM
Who do you think would take it?

TheDoucheyWun
04-14-2010, 08:47 AM
Carwin would kill ubreem.. ubreem has a punchers chance but a very little 1.. dont think shane would exchange in that fight

TBEAR
04-14-2010, 09:55 AM
Carwin by Gnp. Carwin takes him down fast and beats the shit out of AO from side control.

Carwin TKO rd1

lwbrewer
04-14-2010, 10:01 AM
1st you need to get AO to the states [ seems to be a problem] Then get them both in the same promotion.[probely be a problem for AO to sign a UFC contract] Other then that I'm up for the fight.

initial_zen
04-14-2010, 02:12 PM
im going with overeem. If carwin tried to clinch with him he will eat some nasty knees and overeems definitely got the advantage on the feet. Overeem also has a good ground game but if carwin is able to take him down easily then he might be in trouble.

joeyP
04-14-2010, 07:17 PM
Carwin isn't stupid enough to stand with Overeem. As long as he doesn't take a knee while shooting for the takedown I say he takes it by ground and pound, sub, or decision

The Return Of......
05-15-2010, 10:32 PM
1st you need to get AO to the states [ seems to be a problem] Then get them both in the same promotion.[probely be a problem for AO to sign a UFC contract] Other then that I'm up for the fight.

dont forget he has to pass a piss test too

Fedorlei Gomipierre
05-16-2010, 03:39 PM
Carwin has crazy power in his hands, but Overeem has crisp striking to the point of ridiculousness and I think he outpoints Carwin all night long. Carwin's never fought somebody with a good size advantage on him and we know Overeem can take a punch, so I think it all really comes down to the explosiveness in Carwin's shot, because if he can get this to the ground, the striking edge is null and void.

Personally, I think Overeem's power and technical striking will keep Carwin at bey with BRUTAL legkicks and distance too long and eventually Overeem will rock him and sink in the guillotine. I don't think I've ever seen somebody toss a man Rogers' size with the ease Overeem did last night and that scared me a little. Carwin's a big, powerful fighter, but I think Overeem's striking is on another planet and Carwin'll be hardpressed to secure a shot without eating something really grizzly on the way in.

Black
05-16-2010, 06:15 PM
Carwin has crazy power in his hands, but Overeem has crisp striking to the point of ridiculousness and I think he outpoints Carwin all night long. Carwin's never fought somebody with a good size advantage on him and we know Overeem can take a punch, so I think it all really comes down to the explosiveness in Carwin's shot, because if he can get this to the ground, the striking edge is null and void.

Personally, I think Overeem's power and technical striking will keep Carwin at bey with BRUTAL legkicks and distance too long and eventually Overeem will rock him and sink in the guillotine. I don't think I've ever seen somebody toss a man Rogers' size with the ease Overeem did last night and that scared me a little. Carwin's a big, powerful fighter, but I think Overeem's striking is on another planet and Carwin'll be hardpressed to secure a shot without eating something really grizzly on the way in.


while I was reading this I was waiting "NOT" in the end...
Carwin take him down easily and GnP him again easily...

Fedorlei Gomipierre
05-16-2010, 07:39 PM
while I was reading this I was waiting "NOT" in the end...
Carwin take him down easily and GnP him again easily...

Again? Easily? I'm not so sure where this is coming from....

Carwin has never taken on a striker of A) Overeem's caliber and B) Overeem's size and in order to get off a shot, he's going to have to weather some pretty brisk shots of the likes he's never endured.

Seeing how easily Overeem tossed Rogers around, I think Carwin won't be too far off if he cares to clinch and Overeem will take a much more subdued and pinpoint approach and just legkick Carwin's shot into oblivion. Carwin isn't refined enough in any avenue and I see him getting guillotined.

Black
05-16-2010, 09:29 PM
Again? Easily? I'm not so sure where this is coming from....

Carwin has never taken on a striker of A) Overeem's caliber and B) Overeem's size and in order to get off a shot, he's going to have to weather some pretty brisk shots of the likes he's never endured.

Seeing how easily Overeem tossed Rogers around, I think Carwin won't be too far off if he cares to clinch and Overeem will take a much more subdued and pinpoint approach and just legkick Carwin's shot into oblivion. Carwin isn't refined enough in any avenue and I see him getting guillotined.

Carwin is too smart and have too much power for this "steroid boy" , we could argue all day long but its my opinion that Carwin would beat his ass easily...

maakshif
05-16-2010, 10:28 PM
Carwin has crazy power in his hands, but Overeem has crisp striking to the point of ridiculousness and I think he outpoints Carwin all night long. Carwin's never fought somebody with a good size advantage on him and we know Overeem can take a punch, so I think it all really comes down to the explosiveness in Carwin's shot, because if he can get this to the ground, the striking edge is null and void.

Personally, I think Overeem's power and technical striking will keep Carwin at bey with BRUTAL legkicks and distance too long and eventually Overeem will rock him and sink in the guillotine. I don't think I've ever seen somebody toss a man Rogers' size with the ease Overeem did last night and that scared me a little. Carwin's a big, powerful fighter, but I think Overeem's striking is on another planet and Carwin'll be hardpressed to secure a shot without eating something really grizzly on the way in.


Again? Easily? I'm not so sure where this is coming from....

Carwin has never taken on a striker of A) Overeem's caliber and B) Overeem's size and in order to get off a shot, he's going to have to weather some pretty brisk shots of the likes he's never endured.

Seeing how easily Overeem tossed Rogers around, I think Carwin won't be too far off if he cares to clinch and Overeem will take a much more subdued and pinpoint approach and just legkick Carwin's shot into oblivion. Carwin isn't refined enough in any avenue and I see him getting guillotined.

100% agree (would rep you, but got to spread some more around first)...I find it funny how everybody wants to discount guys just because they don't fight in the UFC. Granted Overeem hasn't fought that many great opponents lately in MMA, but he has competed against some of the best strikers in the world in the K-1 tourneys and he does have a decent ground game and a sick guillotine.

Carwin is very intelligent and has a lot of power, but intelligence only does so much against a guy that has just as much power as you and better all around technique. This coming from a guy who is on the Carwin bandwagon. I just don't think he can handle somebody with the striking and strength Overeem has, at this point in his career. I do think he does have a good bit more than just a puncher's chance though.

beardown98
05-17-2010, 01:39 AM
I give it to Carwin in this case because of his wrestling back ground you can insert velasquez here as well as carwin i don't see overeem being able to knock either guy out before they can clinch against the fence and work dirty boxing or single leg take down and gnp. I would love to see these fights though it would be a great striker vs wrestler to see which style comes out on top

Pasha K
05-17-2010, 02:19 AM
Carwin take him down easily and GnP him again easily...

That is a very smart and logical statement, as we all know, they have already fought and Carwin GNP´d him easily, why he would not do that AGAIN?:dry::deadhorse:

S.R>TheKing
05-25-2010, 05:31 PM
Well
Considering both strengths of each fighter its kind of a toss up.
Overeem is one of my favorite fighters but so is carwin.
Carwin is extremely strong.
Striking is ok he has knock out power we have all seen that.
His wrestling is what he would really have to utilize.Gnp would have to be his main weapon against overeem.
Overeem has very high level striking and is more or less a well rounded fighter.
Carwin is a big guy but overeem is huge to especially compared to how we was say when he fought chuck back in pride.
This one is a toss up for me and i cant really decide.
Overeem by ko round three
or
Carwin by tko round 2
Those are my two possible and most likely out comes in my opinion for this dream fight that i hope to see in the future after the eventual fold of crap strikeforce

diceman23
06-02-2010, 04:52 AM
Carwin would just get close and somehow smash Overeem IMHO..Overeem would pose a serious threat at distance with kicks and his knees are deadly of course but Carwin just looks so robust I cant see him letting Overeem dictate the pace with his striking.

GSPvsSILVA2012
06-14-2010, 12:50 PM
Gotta give it to Overeem since he's the better striker and probably wouldn't get taken down.