MMA News Forums » MMA Forums » General MMA Forum

[Paytheplayer]

Originally Posted by Ubermensch

Fedor just look at win to loss records its that easy

It's not that easy though.
Nobody is reading the original post from the thread starter.

Looking forward only...

If this is who is the most dominate fighter ever, then hands down Fedor, there wouldn't even be a poll. It'd be pointless.

[Beowulf]

I'm going to go with Silva.

I think Fedor is the #1 P4P fighter, but the question is who is going to continue to dominate. Fedor will be fighting tougher competition then Silva will be. Arlovski or Barnett have a better shot at beating fedor then Cote or Okami does of beating Silva.

[jokerthief]

Originally Posted by Intellectual

Penn at LW or WW? that i dont know right now. I can see a few that may give him trouble.

Shit, I should have specified this. Assume Penn will stay at lightweight.

[Ubermensch]

Originally Posted by Paytheplayer

It's not that easy though.
Nobody is reading the original post from the thread starter.



If this is who is the most dominate fighter ever, then hands down Fedor, there wouldn't even be a poll. It'd be pointless.

My bad... Well I don't see anyone beating Fedor anytime soon but I can say that about Anderson also. Penn that is uncertain it matters where his head is so I wont vote for him. I think there are guys that can beat Anderson though so I guess I will still go with Fedor.

[Beowulf]

Originally Posted by Ubermensch

My bad... Well I don't see anyone beating Fedor anytime soon but I can say that about Anderson also. Penn that is uncertain it matters where his head is so I wont vote for him. I think there are guys that can beat Anderson though so I guess I will still go with Fedor.

I agree that there are guys that can beat Anderson, just not in the UFC (with the exception of Hendo)

[Kimuras"R"Us]

Originally Posted by maxp84z

I've seen PENN LOSE, I've SEEN SILVA TAP like a little bitch.... NEVER HAVE I SEEN FEDOR DO THAT.... FEDOR HANDS DOWN.... anyone else that chooses Penn or Silva are just nuthuggers that avoid facts... My pick is based strictly on FACT/RECORD.

I have seen you say this before I think. Why do you think it's neccesary to type "like a little bitch" when you say someone taps out? It seems a little over the top and pretty direspectful.


With that said since the poll had nothing to do with the past (making your comments pretty much irrelevant) I'm saying Silva because I think, as Diego said, he has done all the heavy lifting and will just keep decimating the rest of his weight class.

[jokerthief]

Originally Posted by Ubermensch

Penn that is uncertain it matters where his head is so I wont vote for him.

You really think this is the case at LW? I just can't think of a single LW that would stand much of a chance against him. I'm trying though lol. Same goes for the other two as well.

The reason I made this thread is because I really can't decide on this one. I think it's super close between all three.

[Paytheplayer]

Originally Posted by Ubermensch

My bad... Well I don't see anyone beating Fedor anytime soon but I can say that about Anderson also. Penn that is uncertain it matters where his head is so I wont vote for him. I think there are guys that can beat Anderson though so I guess I will still go with Fedor.

Its funny because if you were asking me who I think is the best p4p fighter in the world, the no doubt my list would be Fedor, then Silva.
But just looking at the competition each fighter has, I don't see anybody who could beat Silva at MW right now. I can say the same for Fedor, but with fedor and guys like Barnett and Arlovski, they atleast have a punchers chance. Thats my 2 cents anyways.

When it comes to Penn, I could even put him over Fedor in terms of most likely to continue to dominate his weightclass. But thats only if he kept his mind in MMA, and kept his cardio up. At LW I don't see anybody beating Penn, or even taking him to a decision if he continues to keep his work ethic up.

[Adambomb]

Silva, because middleweight is the weakest division by far. He's already KO'd Hendo and crushed Franklin twice, not to mention another top 10 guy at 185 in Marquardt. Who else will stop him? Filho? He looked awful in his last fight. Lindland? Hendo is better at every aspect of the game than Lindland, and he went to sleep in the 2nd.

Fedor is dominant, but he hasn't yet faced Arlovski, Couture, and Barnett who are among the best in his division. He crushed Sylvia, but Tim usually relies on his size to gain an advantage instead of skill.

Penn has already defeated Gomi, but there are plenty of other top LW's he hasn't faced. Ansen, Melendez, Aoki, Alvarez, etc. While I don't think any of those guys would beat BJ, I think those fights could be very competitive.

[ChrisAM]

Originally Posted by maxp84z

I've seen PENN LOSE, I've SEEN SILVA TAP like a little bitch.... NEVER HAVE I SEEN FEDOR DO THAT.... FEDOR HANDS DOWN.... anyone else that chooses Penn or Silva are just nuthuggers that avoid facts... My pick is based strictly on FACT/RECORD.

Wow, I would tap "like a little bitch" too if someone was about to break my fucking ankle.
And writting in CAPS doesn't help you get your point across, just makes you look retarded. So does doing .... all the time.

It's hard to choose which one is more dominate, I think i'll just stay neutral on that one.