MMA News Forums » MMA Forums » General MMA Forum

[stevequalude]

Last year against Forrest Griffin, Anderson Silva put on one of the most masterful performances in MMA history.

The first minute was a feeling-out process, but in an instant, Anderson Silva came alive when Griffin threw a leg kick. Silva caught the leg effortlessly, punched Griffin, and pushed him away with disdain.

Over the next few minutes, Silva would show absolutely no regard for the striking abilities of Griffin as he pressed forward like Griffin's punches didn't even exist.

He knocked Griffin down for the first time by moving forward, practically at a run, and cut off the angle to make Griffin step directly into a big right hook. Rather than attempting to finish Griffin on the ground, Silva let him up and pursued him relentlessly.

At one point, Silva furiously motioned Griffin forward, goading him to engage. Griffin raised his arms in a shrug, as if to say, "I'm trying my hardest! What else do you want me to do?"

Griffin would move forward though, as he always does, and the results were not good for him.

Silva stood right in front of Griffin, leading with his chin right at the end of Griffin's jab, because Silva had gauged his distance so perfectly that he knew exactly how close Griffin's jabs would be, down to an inch.

Discouraged and overwhelmed, Griffin charged forward one more time, but was stopped senseless by a backpedaling downward jab, right on the reset button.

In victory, Anderson Silva jumped on top of the cage, and stood straight up to his full 6'3" height, and raised his arms above his head. In that image, we saw visually just how high Anderson Silva was over the rest of the competition.



With that image in mind, what are the implications of a possible Anderson Silva retirement in 2010?

A few years ago, Silva said in an interview that he planned on retiring at the age of 35. Well, he turns 35 in April of this year.

Before we get too far into the speculation, we should also consider the remarks of his manager, Ed Soares, who says that Silva plans on completing his contract with the UFC, which has three fights remaining on it.

Still even considering that, Silva could very conceivably finish the contract by the end of 2010.

If he does retire, he'll leave a huge gap in the UFC that now looks potentially much bigger this year than would have looked a few years ago.

Silva has never looked more dominant than he did in his last fight. If he continues his domination, he could very easily tear a big hole in the UFC's roster before his contract is done.

Such a hole didn't matter to the UFC as much in previous years, since the UFC might have gladly traded in Silva for a champion who speaks English more fluidly. If Silva were an English-speaking, trash-talking American, his marketability and value to the UFC might have made him a crossover superstar.

As it stands, Silva is marketable, but serves the UFC nearly as much by being a pillar of UFC dominance.

He is, by most accounts, the pound-for-pound best fighter in the world, and like boxing's Manny Pacquiao, seems to have gotten better as he has moved up in weight.

As a stick-thin welterweight, he was still able to dominate top competitors at the time, like Hayato Sakurai, but he was vulnerable to submissions, and might not have had quite as much knockout power.

At 185 and 205, Silva knocks people senseless and is far more difficult to take down. Even former Olympic wrestler Dan Henderson had great difficulties trying to take Silva to the mat.

The dominance of Silva has allowed the UFC to claim ownership of the best pound-for-pound fighter in the world, as well as the best middleweight.

Had Anderson retired a year ago, the changes resulting from a Silva retirement might not have been nearly as dramatic as they would be if he were to retire today.

If he retired now, not only might the UFC lose its best claim to pound-for-pound supremacy, but it might also loosen its grip on claims to having the best middleweight and light-heavyweight fighters in the world.

Strikeforce's Dan Henderson is already ranked by some as the second-best middleweight in the world. Henderson, or anyone who beats Henderson over the next year, might arguably be able to lay claim to middleweight supremacy, should Silva retire.

The light-heavyweight rankings unanimously hold Lyoto Machida as the leading man, despite his disputed victory over Mauricio Rua.

My personal opinion is that Machida is currently far better than any light-heavyweight outside of the UFC, but that hasn't stopped some analysts from making a case for Strikeforce's champion, Gegard Mousasi.

What makes Anderson Silva's place in this equation important are two things. First of all, if Shogun were to defeat Machida, the UFC light-heavyweight belt would have essentially become a merry-go-round of champions, and I doubt as many people would be as certain of Shogun's supremacy as they were of Machida's before his latest bout.

If Machida beats Shogun impressively, I think that a lot of his naysayers will be silenced, but even then, doubts have already been created in the minds of some of the fans.

Silva is seen by many as a guy who could win the belt, if he didn't care about stepping on Machida's shoes.

Going back to the claim of Mousasi, many observers feel that Silva is a bad match-up for Mousasi, and so even if Mousasi is better than the current UFC champ, the UFC still has the best light-heavyweight in Silva.

Since there are already powerful forces in play waiting for any opportunity to try to take some power away from the UFC, as WAMMA tried when it crowned Shinya Aoki champion, using BJ Penn's short move to welterweight as an excuse.

The retirement of Silva might just be the very moment that the UFC competition and their backers are looking for.

There are, of course, those that would still argue for the supremacy of UFC champions, but Silva has been nothing less than a pillar of strength for Dana White and the UFC. Losing such a pillar is never a good thing.

The UFC would also still have a gigantic advantage in terms of brand recognition, and total roster depth, but the lead advantage would have shrunk remarkably, all with the retirement of one man.



So will Anderson Silva retire this year?

He's said nearly as much in interviews, but at least some of that feeling could be changed if Dana White offers him enough money.

Additionally, the shocking fall of Roy Jones may have lessened Silva's desire to box against him, which was one of the factors that people suggest made Silva wish to retire from MMA.

I came across a third reason in the form of an interview featuring Silva and his friend, Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira. It seems like maybe Silva might remain in MMA as long as his friends are standing there beside him, strengthening him, and maintaining his desire.

Personally, as a fan of MMA, I hope Silva stays to fight at least a few more years, because his "ballet of violence," as Joe Rogan calls it, can simply be a joy to watch.

Those more interested in the politics of MMA who are on either side of the fence that separates UFC fans from Strikeforce fans will probably be cheering either for or against Silva's possible retirement.

Of course, there's also the possibility that Silva might actually lose this year, perhaps even at middleweight. But as dangerous as Nate Marquardt, and Vitor Belfort might be, I'm not exactly holding my breath on the possibility.



Here's the video interview I mentioned, featuring Silva and Nogueira, the spider and the minotaur.

YouTube - FIGHT! Life: The Spider & The Minotaur

Anderson Silva: Will He Retire As Champion in 2010? | Bleacher Report

[v3xi]

For some reason, and I have nothing to base this on, but I think he will retire before he can face another legitimate opponent. Vitor? Come on guys, you must have voted that Forrest had a chance too.

I think Silva will retire before he fights somebody like Marquart.

[built1052]

I am so tired of hearing anderson is the p4p best fighter in the world. I'm sorry but if him and Fedor fought at a catch weight Fedor would crush him. The UFC hype machine is pathetic. And I agree that he won't have a legit opponent again before he retires. I see the GSP fight never happening because we all know that Silva's weak spot is his ground game and GSP would GnP him into a TKO.

[Masscore]

Belfort is not an easy fight for Silva and I am actually picking him to pull the upset and win the fight. Silva has not faced a guy that is as fast and as heavy handed as Belfort is at MW. Belfort's hand speed is scary and he might be the first guy Silva has faced that is actually faster then him. And everyone forgets that Belfort has a pretty legit ground game as well. I mean this is a guy that use to out grapple big HWs (Herring). Its going to come down to Silva's range and Mauy Thai against Belfort's speed and boxing. Either way its going to a pretty close and exicting fight.

If he wins that fight I could actually see Silva being the first two time champion in the UFC. If Shogun beats Machida I would almost put money on the UFC doing Shogun v. Silva. If he wins the LHW belt I do not see him retiring until he defends it which would push him into 2011.

[jlruthven84]

Originally Posted by built1052

I am so tired of hearing anderson is the p4p best fighter in the world. I'm sorry but if him and Fedor fought at a catch weight Fedor would crush him. The UFC hype machine is pathetic. And I agree that he won't have a legit opponent again before he retires. I see the GSP fight never happening because we all know that Silva's weak spot is his ground game and GSP would GnP him into a TKO.

Wow, dude...just...wow.

You act like Silva isn't even within pissing distance of Fedor. Shit, if that fight happened, I'm not 100% sure Fedor wouldn't have serious problems...and that's something I've rarely said. Silva's got the reach, the striking advantage (as long as we're being honest), and if given the chance, could into a really good heavyweight shape.

Seeing as how that fight ain't happening, though, let's talk about a potential superfight with GSP. Again, you make it seem like a victory by GSP would be all but a foregone conclusion. Silva would have a substantial reach on him, a considerable striking advantage (despite how good GSP's kickboxing has gotten), and a ground game that he'd kill you for sneezing at. I agree, and most people would, that Silva's long achilles' heel is his wrestling, but Dan Henderson wasn't able to do shit with him even WHEN he got him down. And guess what happened to Hendo when that fight went to the ground again? Yeah.

On topic, there are a couple of things that would have to happen for Silva to not retire once his contract is up: 1) he loses the title to either Belfort or Marquardt. 2) Machida loses the title to Shogun. 3) Both.

If his trend of dominance continues, though, I for one would be okay with him bowing out unless the UFC somehow snags Mousasi.

[the_dark_angel_4ever]

Personally I see Anderson getting a bit too caught up in his own hype and getting caught against Vitor. I'd love to see it actually and I'm a big Spider fan. Imagine a reinvigorated, refocused Anderson coming back after losing his title and simply going on a rampage ala GSP after his loss to Serra. It would also motivate Anderson to sign a new contract and not retire just yet.

[RKO7645]

Originally Posted by built1052

I am so tired of hearing anderson is the p4p best fighter in the world. I'm sorry but if him and Fedor fought at a catch weight Fedor would crush him. The UFC hype machine is pathetic. And I agree that he won't have a legit opponent again before he retires. I see the GSP fight never happening because we all know that Silva's weak spot is his ground game and GSP would GnP him into a TKO.

Okay i understand this is your opinion....

I do think Fedor would beat Anderson in a fight but Fedor is also a heavyweight. Anderson would have a serious chance against Fedor. Every fight starts on the feet and seeing as how Fedor has no problem in striking with opponents for a stretch of a fight Anderson would do quite well. Anderson would be in trouble if Fedor got on top of him but I think Anderson could hold his own.

Against GSP, Anderson would be much bigger, just as fast as GSP as well as have the striking and reach advantage. GSP may be able to get Silva to the ground but holding down a fighter as big as Anderson is much different than holding down a welterweight.

No legit opponent? Do you know how much talent Vitor has? Nate the Great? Those are very legit opponents IMO.

[GSPvsSILVA2012]

If Silva retires without facing at least one of these guys: Machida, GSP, Fedor, Lesnar, Mir, Rampage, Rashad it would be very disappointing. The best guy he beat isn't even a top 10 p4p fighter. He's lost 4 times....I still have that in the back of my mind that Silva can lose to a lot of people and he's not as good as the UFC makes him out to be. He just keeps fighting Leites, Cote type competition excluding hendo\mardquart ofc.

[roaddawg]

Originally Posted by v3xi

For some reason, and I have nothing to base this on, but I think he will retire before he can face another legitimate opponent. Vitor? Come on guys, you must have voted that Forrest had a chance too.

I think Silva will retire before he fights somebody like Marquart.

Yea I think he will retire before he beats the crap out of Marquart again.

[hass]

I wonder why Anderson hasn't gotten somewhat near the criticism Fedor has gotten about the list of opponents he has beaten. Lots of arguments went around that Fedor's opponents have not always been top quality, don't remember any regarding Anderson's opponents.

Personally, I don't think either fighter deserves any criticism for whom they've fought, great list of opponents for both. But, I do feel Anderson's biggest fights should be ahead of him. Franklin, Henderson, and Marquardt were probably his toughest opponents and definitely his biggest fights. Lutter, Leben, Cote, and Irvin delayed bigger/better fights for Anderson, with all do respect.

Basically, middleweight a couple of rematches left for Anderson. Light Heavyweight is where all of the big matchups await. And to make absolute history, Anderson can make his run at heavyweight and possibly become the best in MMA history, bar none.

It all depends on motivation, desire for competition, and of course lots of frigging money.
.
.
.
(Fedor would win)