MMA News Forums » MMA Forums » General MMA Forum

[Matt Boone]

FROM: http://www.sherdog.com/news/articles.asp?n_id=5022

Dean: “Shamrock Was Out”
July 12, 2006
by Jake Rossen (jakerossen@gmail.com)

The more raucous boos on Saturday’s UFC 61: “Bitter Rivals” card were reserved for referee Herb Dean (Pictures), who oversaw the second confrontation between rivals Ken Shamrock (Pictures) and Tito Ortiz (Pictures).

Months of hype and harsh words were distilled into just 78 seconds of action when Dean halted the bout after Shamrock received a series of elbows from Ortiz. Though Shamrock appeared listless and unable to stop the attack, his casual post-fight demeanor incited the roughly 12,400 in attendance to direct their ire at Dean.

“I stopped the fight because he received five elbows without any attempt to defend himself,” Dean explained to Sherdog.com Tuesday afternoon. “I believe he was unconscious. I think he was out with the first one.”

After a brief scuffle, Ortiz deposited Shamrock on his back and used arching elbows to deliver five clean strikes directly to Shamrock’s face. “At that critical time, he was unable to defend himself,” Dean recounted. “I was certain of that. I can’t think of another reason to take five elbows without doing anything else.”

Once Dean separated the athletes, Shamrock popped up and appeared to be unfazed by the barrage.

“I can’t be accountable for how fast he’s going to recover,” Dean said.

Upon review of the fight and consulting with the Nevada State Athletic Commission, Dean believes he made the right — if not popular — choice.

“The commission believed it was a good call,” the referee said. “I’m not popular right now, but I don’t think it was a bad call. I hated to see the fight end like that. I’ll let guys go as long as they’re able to fight back. But at that point, he wasn’t.

“I’m going to have to make calls that people aren’t going to be happy about. That’s my job. I can’t do what everyone else wants. It’s my conscience.”

Vacationing with family this week, Shamrock was unavailable for comment.

[Kewl144]

note: "I can’t think of another reason to take five elbows without doing anything else.”

[Alvin]

Maybe Shamrock was simply trying to smell Tito's under-arm deodorant?

[Matt Boone]

...I'm thinking probably no.

[Kewl144]

Originally Posted by Alvin

Maybe Shamrock was simply trying to smell Tito's under-arm deodorant?

Maybe Shamrock likes the color purple?

[Matt Boone]

ahahaahah

[killerinstinct]

Bottom line is Ken wasn't defending himself b/c he never had a chance to defend him self.A couple of quick elbows is no reason to EVER stop a fight! The least Herb could've done for the UFC HOF is give him a verbal warning before stopping the fight(like most intelligent referees do).Herb Dean made a bad call that fans aren't going to forget anytime soon.Most people bought the ppv for the sole purpose of seeing Tito/Shamrock II and Herb fucking ruined that for all of us.

[Kewl144]

Originally Posted by killerinstinct

Bottom line is Ken wasn't defending himself b/c he never had a chance to defend him self.A couple of quick elbows is no reason to EVER stop a fight! The least Herb could've done for the UFC HOF is give him a verbal warning before stopping the fight(like most intelligent referees do).Herb Dean made a bad call that fans aren't going to forget anytime soon.Most people bought the ppv for the sole purpose of seeing Tito/Shamrock II and Herb fucking ruined that for all of us.

It'll be forgotten long before another season of TUF floods the fan base again. Herb made a good call and a professional call. People just feel cheated because the fight was hyped for so long. But really, who actually believed that it would turn out any other way? And isnt Herb the only UFC ref. who has also fought before?

[liddell316]

Yeah, a verbal warning I guess should have happened....but those wern't five quick elbows, they wern't that fast. And Shamrock didn't move at all...that's a clear cut sign he was out of it.

[Kewl144]

This was Ken's special "ass" defense again Sakuraba and he complained after that one as well...common theme? If you stop defending yourself, the fight will end.