MMA News Forums » MMA Forums » Noob Jack City

[TheDirtySis]

Originally Posted by jasonIndiana

10. antonio nogueira 29-4-1
9. dan henderson 22-5
8. cheick kongo 20-3-1
7. rashad evans 16-0-1
6. forrest giffin 16-4
5. quinton jackson 28-6
4. tim sylvia 27-3
3. matt huges 43-5
2. GPS 14-2
1. anderson silva 21-4

Do you know what P4P rankings mean?

[Brutus]

Originally Posted by jasonIndiana

i wont argue for roger huerta i dont know what i was thinking im changing that. but the fact is the penn did lose those fights and is not ranked any better than a 7 or 8 in any weight class at mmaweekly.com or sherdog.com.

if you feel so strongly about those site's rankings, you should go there and post instead of here. get a clue as to what pound for pound means, then come back. then start a retraction thread for this one.

[jasonIndiana]

if i dont know what it means then explain it

[Brutus]

Originally Posted by jasonIndiana

if i dont know what it means then explain it

see my previous post

[jasonIndiana]

you have no clue what your talking about. pound 4 pound is the best fighter at any weight class.

[Brutus]

Originally Posted by jasonIndiana

you have no clue what your talking about. pound 4 pound is the best fighter at any weight class.

hahahahahaha....ok little buddy, ur right. i give up. thats why tim sylvia, evans and kongo are on that list right?

do u wear a helmet?

EDIT: SEE ABOVE AVATAR

[jasonIndiana]

big nog has fought at HW and LHW and done great any poll
hendo two weight class champ in pride but loss to rampage
kongo has fought HW and LHW and is on a rush
evans hasnt lost at 205 and won TUF as a HW
forrest just beat shogun who was said to be number 1
and i hope you can figure out the top 5 without someone explaining with to you.

[TheDirtySis]

Originally Posted by jasonIndiana

if i dont know what it means then explain it

Quite easily it is a ranking based more on skill than fighter vs fighter. In boxing terms it means Floyd mayweather is the P4P king but he couldnt beat Wladimir Klitchko. Likewise Wladamir doesnt have the boxing skills Mayweather does.

This applies to MMA. BJ penn loses a dec. to a LHW Machida, Thats impressive. GSP showing that he can out-wrestler the Natl champion wrestler and out strike strikers show how phenomenal he is. Heavyweights dont make P4P list unless they are truly skilled like Fedor. Randy makes a lot of lists cuz he has won multiple championships at different weights.

Do you kinda get it now. Its not what would happen if BJ fought Sylvia. Sylvia would stomp him. But if they weighed the same and had the same skill sets that they have now who would win. IMO BJ could win LHW or HW with his skill set if he was indeed naturally 205 or 225+. The other weight classes Have other fighters that could win other weight classes. Former/future champ GSP and Anderson Silva could win at LHW if they were born that big.

[jasonIndiana]

Originally Posted by Hunchbacked Lemur

hahahahahaha....ok little buddy, ur right. i give up. thats why tim sylvia, evans and kongo are on that list right?

do u wear a helmet?

EDIT: SEE ABOVE AVATAR

whats your top ten big guy since you say things like i dont know anything and you dont post a ten list but bash mine.

[Brutus]

Originally Posted by jasonIndiana

big nog has fought at HW and LHW and done great any poll
hendo two weight class champ in pride but loss to rampage
kongo has fought HW and LHW and is on a rush
evans hasnt lost at 205 and won TUF as a HW
forrest just beat shogun who was said to be number 1
and i hope you can figure out the top 5 without someone explaining with to you.

if you are correct fine, but i dont see kongo fighting at 205. i didnt even look to see if he'd faught there b/c is so far fetched based on the fact he fucking huge and ripped. evans hasnt beet anyone noteable and forrest has only faught at 1 weight class. hendo is definately a top p4p guy, along w/ those i have mentioned b4, no one else is even inthe ballpark. forrest lost to a hw contender on tuf, which is a negative shot at him being a p4p guy. you have no credibility and should just be quiet.

didnt you say that you werent talking about pride before too??