MMA News Forums » MMA Forums » Noob Jack City

[jasonIndiana]

10. antonio nogueira 29-4-1
9. dan henderson 22-5
8. wandy
7. rashad evans 16-0-1
6. forrest giffin 16-4
5. quinton jackson 28-6
4. tim sylvia 27-3
3. matt huges 43-5
2. GPS 14-2
1. anderson silva 21-4

[jasonIndiana]

[QUOTE=osuwrestling]Your list is very, very bad.



its not your five fav fighters
i based my ten off of what has happen in their last couple of fights.
BJ Penn is 2-2-1 in his last 5 fights. you put henderson over rampage? when he lost to rampage. good call

[magic marker]

i might get flamed, but in no particular order:
1. couture
2. rampage
3. a. silva
4. gsp
5. toss up between sherk and penn
6. hughes
7. hendo
8. toss up between chuck and wandy
9. maybe fedor
10. maybe jardine

there's probably different ones i could name, but these are the first that come to mind.

[Jem7dbk]

1. A. Silva
2. Rampage
3. Hendo
4. GSP
5. BJ Penn

[jasonIndiana]

the question is P4P in the ufc. this isnt pride were hendo was a two weight class title holder. hes not a 3/4 205pounder in the world or even in the ufc but he is a 5/6 but at 185 he is not even top ten and he wont beat silva. and PJ penn can only fight at 155 he cant hack it at 170.......see thats how that works.

[rivethead]

[QUOTE=jasonIndiana]

Originally Posted by osuwrestling

Your list is very, very bad.



its not your five fav fighters
i based my ten off of what has happen in their last couple of fights.
BJ Penn is 2-2-1 in his last 5 fights. you put henderson over rampage? when he lost to rampage. good call

Do you even understand what Pound for Pound means?

If you are just basing off "their last fights" how can you not have Matt Serra, a natural 155 pounder at #1? He holds a win over GSP, who is a natural WW. I don't "feel" he's a better fighter than GSP, but by your logic, as the only fighter to currently hold a title above his natural weight class, Serra should be #1...at least till he fights again.

That being said, Hendo is P4P much better than Rampage.

rh

[jasonIndiana]

[QUOTE=rivethead

Do you even understand what Pound for Pound means?



rh[/QUOTE]


i base a little off their last fights just like everyone does, also who they fight, and inactivity. so do you what P4P means? if fighters lose fights they dont remain the number one fighter. do they? i dont think so. how can someone like penn be a top 5 P4P when going 2-3 in his last 5 fights and 1-2 in his last 3? and matt serras a joke

[XitdiesXtodayX]

Have you even watched Penns last fights?Many would argue that he shouldve won that fight with GSP,and he did have Hughes beat the first couple of rounds.Penn belongs on the list due to how well he has done in numerous weight classes.You have Roger Huerta a guy thats biggest win is over Clay Guida in your top 5.How the hell does that work?

[Brutus]

you have no clue as to what you are talking about. Tim Sylvia a top p4p fighter?? pound 4 pound is not based at all on the last couple of fights. its basically based on how well you would/have do/done against those under, at your own, and above your own weight class.

the only fighters that make any real sense on ur list, indiana, are GSP and prolly the #1 p4p fighter in the world, anderson silva. and he's ranked 10 out of 10.

You should be shot for that list.

[jasonIndiana]

Originally Posted by XitdiesXtodayX

Have you even watched Penns last fights?Many would argue that he shouldve won that fight with GSP,and he did have Hughes beat the first couple of rounds.Penn belongs on the list due to how well he has done in numerous weight classes.You have Roger Huerta a guy thats biggest win is over Clay Guida in your top 5.How the hell does that work?

i wont argue for roger huerta i dont know what i was thinking im changing that. but the fact is the penn did lose those fights and is not ranked any better than a 7 or 8 in any weight class at mmaweekly.com or sherdog.com.