That was sickening, Corey Hill all over again. Damn I don't think Anderson is coming back from that. Who knows what could have happened had that not happen.....i think fans were robbed of a great fight, it was a freak injury for sure. I guess I'll give credit to Weidman, but he won't be the best MW in the world until he beat Vitor IMO. And honestly I think Vitor eats his soul...but he Weidman has a bad habit of proving me wrong....
I agree with all except for the freak injury part but it seems like my definition of a freak injury is vastly different than the rest of the forum apparently. I wish that Weidman could've knocked him out or submitted or had a one sided decision to remove all doubt and ammunition from haters but this ending did not do so.
Originally Posted by joeodd2
Also, it is obviously terrible to see someone get so badly injured in the sport that we all love even though I can't stand Silva. Even though I dont like him I still respect him as the greatest fighter of this generation and that is not the way I wanted to see him go out.
Freak accident my ass. That was a proper leg kick check. A freak accident was when Korean Zombie dislocated his own shoulder throwing a punch or Jon Jones damn near ripping his own big toe off because of a loose octagon plank. Leg kicks are high risk high reward for a reason Weidmen just proved it.
There have been many checked leg kicks in the ufc and only two that ended up like that, so I'd say it could be considered a freak accident. Maybe accident is a bad word choice. How about freak incident?
Originally Posted by somethindarker
It's a damn shame that Silva vs. Weidman ended that way. Now we will never know for sure who would have won that fight without the freak incident. It's a damn shame especially since it might end Anderson Silva's career earlier than anyone expected or wanted.
It's interesting how Anderson fans have to make excuses when he gets finished.
I guess we'll never know how, say the Lutter fight would have ended, if he hadn't had a terrible weight cut. Or how the Henderson fight would have ended, if he hadn't had a bad weight cut as well. Or how the first sonnen fight would have ended if chael actually had the ability to pound as well as ground.
Does that shit sound incredibly stupid? Good. It should. So does the whining about the way the fight ended.
Silva had a hole in his technique. Weidman exposed it. It wasn't a freak incident. It was a fight.
It wasn't like Weidman slipped on some water and checked the kick by accident. It wasn't like Anderson stumbled and threw the kick off balance. It was a planned, executed action and a planned, executed reaction. The reaction won.
Yes, the leg broke, and it was gruesome, but even if it hadn't broken, by checking effectively, Weidman intentionally took away Anderson's most effective weapon. Even if the leg hadn't snapped, if Anderson had just injured it, or even got a hairline fracture, he wasn't going to throw effective kicks for the rest of the night. Even if it was just tender, he was going to lose mobility, he was going to lose the ability to injure with it. It was going to hamper him defending takedowns, and he'd already be pwned in the first round with 4 healthy limbs.
After that check, he was going to lose. Even if the leg didn't break, he was going to lose.
If he somehow came back and won, that would have been the freak anomaly. Not the other way around.
Even if you lovelovelove Anderson, anyone who is looking at the fight objectively should see this. You are doing yourself a disservice by pretending the fight was going to end any other way than with Anderson losing.
Again, this is like the guys who felt Fedor tapping to Werdum was due to his "arrogance." It makes the poster/writer/speaker sound like an idiot.
Two guys went into the cage. Both had a plan. Both had trained for it.
One guy won. Clearly. Cleanly. Due to his own action, not some horrible twist of fate.
Between the two fights we have over 3 rounds and Chris won every round in points scored a KO & got a TKO. Chris had Silva's number per say yes Silva may of gotten a sub if Chris made a mistake, other wise it was Chris's fight to lose. If Chris didn't have Silva's # he wouldn't of won the first round. Even though Silva lost twice he still is one of the greastest fighters
One thing's clear, there will always be two camps when it comes to what constitutes a "freak accident" in this fight. And I'll always side with this being a "freak accident" based on the thousand of leg kicks I've witnessed over the years. It's also sad the Weidman couldn't prove beyond all doubt that he is the better fighter. Maybe this makes him a better champion, or maybe not. But that what I think and it will NEVER change, reserve the right to respectfully disagree with all those who see otherwise. So moving on to something else.
SEE WHAT FUCKING HAPPENS WHEN YOU USE YOUR FUCKING JAB URIAH HALL!?!? Sweet Baby Jesus that's the motherfucker I was excited to see jump all in the MW division's shit and whoop some ass. To be fair I think Leban is a shell of his former self and should retire. But Even a younger leban would have been stopped by this guy. I'm still a little concerned about his reliance on reflexes and speed for some of his defense, but he did block a few shots. Loved the step in Knees and I think when ever he throws that round house head kick his opponent's heart skips a beat. Excellent Excellent performance by Hall, 2 or 3 more mid level fights and it's time to start talking about a top contender for this kid. One thing is for sure the post-Anderson Silva Middle Weight division will be full of fun fights and lots of Title Changes IMO.
Rhonda Rousey, damn this angry woman turns me the fuck on! I love it, she doesn't forgive shit and she fights that way. She stood tough and exchanged with Tate, took some good shot in the process. But it was always clear what she wanted and on the ground she's like a shark in water, I don't think alot of men(under 200 lbs) could out grapple her, let alone women. Her hips are some of the fastest and strongest I've ever seen. She reversed how many take downs? It's almost unfair how superior her technique is to most in her division. I'm gonna start calling her No Love. I'm starting to revise my belief that Cyborg would destroy her, I think it would be a 50/50 fight now.
Damn I hated to see the warmaster taken out like that, but Browne is the real deal. sometimes guys hold on to that single or double to long and push through those elbows, but when a guy that tall has leverage.......fuuuuuuuck bruh..
Was hoping for a Barnett/Leben win, both guys don't deserve to go out like they did last night that's for sure. They deserved better than that. Leben's best days are far behind him as a fighter.
So it's that unusual for Anderson to lose the 1st round in his fights? How about the first round of the Chael Sonnen rematch? then what happened in the second? It's impossible to say what could have happened in that fight minus that injury. but hey I said I'd leave this issue alone didn't I? but goddamn it's hard to......
Originally Posted by lwbrewer