It comes down to one thing. Do you (A) look at the hall of fame is a chronicling of significant people and events in the sport, or (B) do you look at it as a place to honor the very best? If you go with (A) then he absolutely should be in the hall of fame. If you go with (B) then hell no. It is the opposite for Jon Fitch. Just by looking at which guy is in, and which guy doesn't have a snowballs chance in hell, should show you the UFC's school of though on the matter.