Someone Help Me Out: Mayweather Beat GSP & Pacquiao For 2010 ESPY?
Posted on Jul 15, 2010
By MATT BOONE
MMANEWS.COM Staff Writer


Wait a second. Someone has to help me out here. Did Floyd Mayweather really take home the ESPY for "Best Fighter" after the award ceremony on ESPN this past Wednesday night? I'm not sure which is more offensive: the "decision-makers" behind the ESPY winners for selecting Mayweather as best fighter, or Mayweather for having the gull to accept the award and actually go home with it as if he legitimately earned it.

After clearing up some confusion I had in my 2010 ESPY Awards recap article earlier today, I have become confused about something completely different. In the article, I pondered whether or not fights Mayweather and Georges St-Pierre had in 2010 counted towards the voting. From a completely speculative standpoint, I assumed they had to, otherwise Mayweather won the award for a lone victory over a man in Juan Manuel Marquez who fought multiple weight classes higher than his fighting weight for the first time in his pro career.

Certainly that doesn't warrant the nod over UFC welterweight champion GSP, who by comparison took out B.J. Penn, a top-five (at the time) pound-for-pound ranked fighter who was also a UFC world champion (also at the time) inside the five-round distance before successfully defending his welterweight title against the division's number one contender in Thiago Alves. A fight, by the way, that St-Pierre won after toughing out multiple rounds with a torn abductor muscle that he suffered during the fight.

« Last Page  |   Page 1 of 5   |  Next Page »


P Spartan
Reputation: 0
Join Date: Jul 16th, 10
Location:
Posts: 1
Posted :
Rated This Post : 0

Title..
Mayweather def deserved award. jmm and mosley are two legends in boxing. Cant say the same for hardy and alves. bj of course is a legend. and mayweather is known for not taking his first few rounds every fight because he reads fighters and then attacks later on. watch his fights. second of all pacman is awesome but hatton is overrated and cotto was gettin smoked by everyone at the time. love gsp and pacman but its gotta go to pretty boy floyd.
Alex Russ
Reputation: 0
Join Date: Jun 4th, 10
Location: England
Posts: 3
Posted :
Rated This Post : 0

Title..
It's a disgrace that Mayweather was given the award, it should have gone to Pacman. I personally don't understand how other MMA fighters (in particular, Anderson Silva - much as I hate the guy, he destroyed a former champion in Forrest Griffin in the first round) were not even given nominations.

Whilst I can understand GSP not getting the nod this year, it would be nice if the ESPY award could at least give a bit of credit to MMA rather than always awarding the boxers.
Ty Foster
Reputation: 0
Join Date: Jul 15th, 10
Location: japan
Posts: 1
Posted :
Rated This Post : 0

ESPY
ESPY award timeframe is from June to June so GSP win over BJ 1/31/2009 would have went towards LAST YEAR not this year. With that being said in no way what so ever would beating Hardy and Alves warrant the award over beating JMM and Mosley (who at the time was considered one of the p4p best in the sport. Mayweather deserved the award he got.
Jacob Marks
Reputation: 0
Join Date: Mar 21st, 10
Location: El Paso, Texas
Posts: 1236
Posted :
Rated This Post : 0

ESPY's
Agree on Mayweather/ESPY. You can debate him not even deserving a nomination. I wanted to see GSP take it, but if I'm being honest, I felt Pacman deserved it again this year.