On Saturday night, the mixed martial arts leader returned for its latest pay-per-view event, UFC 305.

For the first time this year, the UFC was Down Under this week, where Perth's RAC Arena played host to the promotion’s latest Australian show. And the promotion brought with it across the globe a notable lineup that included a title fight and a host of intriguing undercard scraps.

Elsewhere, former flyweight title challengers Kai Kara-France and Steve Erceg looked to stake their claims for a second shot at UFC gold in the co-main event, while Oceanic fan favorites Dan Hooker and Tai Tuivasa also hoped to deliver standout triumphs on the main card.

But did all those names come together to put on an entertaining night of fights? Let's find out with all the positives and negatives from UFC 305.

Positive - Don't Be Silly...You Know The Rest

Jesus Aguilar has two hobbies (among other things, I'm sure. Perhaps he's partial to some ballroom dancing. Who knows?) — fighting Australians and locking in guillotine chokes. Combining them must have been like Christmas at UFC 305.

The Mexican entered the cage as an underdog for the first fight of the night in Perth, which many expected to be a coming out party for Australia's newest hot prospect, the previously undefeated Stewart Nicoll.

In Las Vegas last year, Ross was absolutely obliterated on the feet by Aguilar in just 17 seconds in one of 2023's most brutal knockouts. Nicoll's demise came on the ground when he had his strong start rendered null after getting caught in Aguilar's favorite submission move. The Mexican was, indeed, not silly. When the opportunity presented itself, he jumped the gilly and put Nicoll out — not that anybody bar Aguilar actually noticed.

That left a scary visual of the Aussie wide-eyed as his sleeping body fell back. On another note, could the referee not have maybe caught his head as it thundered onto the canvas? It feels like we regularly see superhero saves from officials in Muay Thai fights over in Asia, but on this occasion, it looked like the ref practically dodged Nicoll's head.

Regardless, the finish was incredibly impressive from Aguilar, who now has five guillotines out of his six fight-ending chokes.

Accept a bout with Aguilar at your peril, Australian flyweights!

Negative - What One Burns Can Do, The Other Burns... Well, Can't

Herbert Burns, however, is a veteran of that group.

It's fascinating to watch back Burns' knockout of Nate Landwehr in 2020. I try not to buy into 'fluke' narratives, but that is a compelling one. Since then, the Brazilian has lost four straight by TKO, two of which have been the same type of retirement.

Against both Bill Algeo in 2022 and Jack Jenkins on Saturday night, "The Blaze" — an apt moniker for someone whose UFC career has gone up in smoke — responded to adversity by attempting to pull guard and collapsing to his back when desperation takedowns failed.

After a while of doing so in both instances, Keith Peterson and Marc Goddard waved the bouts off. With the memory of the Algeo fight growing ever clearer as Burns' UFC 305 bout played out, I remarked to colleagues, "He'll do it (fall to his back) enough times until Goddard stops it." Like clockwork.

Of course, credit has to go to Jenkins for his performance on home soil. Regardless of the opposition level, "Phar" looked on it in the striking realm. But his crisp boxing wasn't enough to override the negative that is Burns' latest disastrous display inside the Octagon.

Negative - A Mess

Well, the UFC 305 featured prelim when swimmingly, didn't it?

Where to begin. The clash between Junior Tafa and Valter Walker brought with it an abundance of negatives — and no, the referee's decision-making was absolutely not one of them.

The fight's conclusion came after the Brazilian clutched onto his Aussie counterpart's leg and locked in a heel hook. Things suddenly came to an end, with replays showing that Tafa had yelled out in pain. That stoppage ended up being controversial, not because it was wrong, but because the sport's leading promotion employs commentators who don't know the ruleset of what they're tasked with describing to a global audience.

It's remarkable to say, but we had two legendary former champions, Daniel Cormier and Dominick Cruz, questioning the third man inside the cage. The latter — who never shies away from using his agenda against Keith Peterson to slam referees — even went as far as to group the moment with instances of fighters having their chance to compete cruelly taken away.

Guys...Read. The. Rules.

Verbal tap out: When a contestant verbally announces to the referee that he or she does not wish to continue or makes audible sounds such as screams indicating pain or discomfort.

The fact we had to sit through five minutes of doubting the referee's decision before texts from those better informed arrived to save the day is yet further evidence as to why Laura Sanko needs to be a permanent fixture on the commentary desk.

The negatives didn't stop there, however.

An unhappy Tafa responded by butting heads with Walker before slapping him. The UFC has been pretty inconsistent when it comes with dealing with similar instances — Khabib Nurmagomedov continued his title reign post-instigating the UFC 229 brawl, while Paul Daley was cut and forever ousted from the promotion for his sucker punch against Josh Koscheck at UFC 113.

What happens next in the career of Tafa remains to be seen, but a release shouldn't be out of the question.

Positive - Nightmare? I'll Say

The welterweight division always seems to have one major prospect establishing himself as one to watch, with recent years seeing Shavkat Rakhmonov and Ian Garry following successful arrivals with climbs into title contention.

All signs point toward Carlos Prates joining them soon enough.

There aren't enough superlatives to do justice to the Brazilian's performance. He became the first man to knock out Li Jingliang, but his display was by no means defined by a sudden fight-ending sequence. Prates frankly beat "The Leech" up for the best part of nine minutes.

That's evidently what it was going to take to get the returning Chinese fighter out of there — soften up what's long been an iron chin with knockdown after knockdown, before uncorking one of the most clubbing hooks in recent memory to finish the job.

Add Prates to the list of, "Oh, he's on the card? Hell yeah," fighters in the UFC.

Negative - The Worst Scorecard In UFC History

Considering I'm often leaping to the defense of judges, who frequently come under fire from individuals with no concept of how mixed martial arts fights are scored, it feels good to be able to grab a pitchfork this time around.

Even while writing this, I'm still in shock at the scorecard. 30-27 Tai Tuivasa. You'd be hard pressed to make an argument for "Bam Bam" getting one round over Jairzinho Rozenstruik on Saturday night, yet alone two, yet alone three.

"Bigi Boy" was clinical with his performance, piecing Tuivasa up while avoiding virtually all of the home favorite's power shots. Judge Howie Booth, however, must have gotten the red and blue corners confused because it's hard to see any other explanation for his work at UFC 305.

Thankfully, he was relieved from his duties for the rest of the night (not that it mattered anyway given how the co-main event finished...more on that soon). But, to be honest, that scorecard is so bad that Howie probably shouldn't be with scorecard in hand ever again.

Even hours later, I'm still trying to recall a scorecard that even comes close. Chris Lee's 48-47 in favor of Paul Felder over Rafael dos Anjos, perhaps?

Positive - He's Back

It's 2024 and Dan Hooker is in the lightweight top five (or at least should be come next week's update). Redemption arcs don't come much better than that.

Hooker entered the cage at UFC 305 with an almighty task ahead of him, getting his wish to feature on the card granted in the form of a showdown with the highly regarded Mateusz Gamrot. Be it odds, fans, or analysts, basically every metric had "The Hangman" falling short to the smothering grappling of "Gamer."

But the New Zealander's promise to fight through relentless takedown attempts and make Gamrot pay with his striking weapons came to fruition. For the most part, though, he actually gave as good as he got on the feet.

Round one saw both men exchange knockdowns, before the second frame was more a tail of the Polish fighter's control versus Hooker's strikes while defending Gamrot's wrestling. And the concluding stanza was just a war that can be summed up by two-and-a-half minutes of striking success each.

Judge that.

Two cageside scorers ultimately leant the way of "The Hangman," and with that he's rendered the 1-4 run he entered UFC 281 in 2022 riding a distance memory. And with three straight wins and a triumph over a name like Gamrot, he is well and truly back in the mix.

If Dustin Poirier is looking for one last hurrah...rematch, anyone?

Positive - Did You Blink?

Speaking of underdogs who made a mockery of their betting lines...

Steve Erceg was perhaps one or two ill-advised takedowns away from a shock title win in Brazil this past May. And his efforts left many heavily favoring him to bounce back at the expense of the returning Kai Kara-France at UFC 305.

But in the words of the New Zealander's teammate Israel Adesanya, "Y'all must have forgot."

After spending over a year on the sidelines recovering from a concussion and taking all the necessary precautions to protect his health, Kara-France made a splash in his comeback by knocking "AstroBoy" out in the very first round. You'd be hard pressed to find a bingo card that had that finish on it.

With Kai Asakura's signing and Kara-France's emphatic performance on Saturday night, Alexandre Pantoja isn't short on possible challenges. And with that, the flyweight division remains among the most exciting, and one in which you absolutely should not blink.

Positive - Respect

it always seemed unlikely that the UFC 305 main event would disappoint. It was just always going to deliver, wasn't it? But even so, what we got in Perth was special.

I can't remember the last time I was as enthralled by a headline matchup to the extent I was when Dricus Du Plessis defended his middleweight title against Israel Adesanya. It saw two top athletes with polar-opposite styles come together to be about as evenly matched as possible.

Add in a bit of a feud, the story of Adesanya's return, and Du Plessis' continued habit of proving his sizable group of doubters wrong, and you've got all the ingredients for a Fight of the Year contender.

Through three rounds, I had the champ leading 29-28, but that was by no means a clear and easy score. As has been the case with the South African in the past, the tale was his power shorts versus his opponents' volume. In the end, after that had already put him up on the scorecards, "Stillknocks" connected hard in a fourth frame that had been all Adesanya, eventually putting him down and locking in a rear-naked choke.

The positives here are all around, from the entertaining nature of the fight to the pair's respectful exchange in the Octagon in the aftermath to Adesanya's humble approach to another setback.

Du Plessis, of course, deserves the main plaudits. He is beginning to amass a largely unrivaled résumé in the UFC, with his 8-0 record including a knockout of Robert Whittaker and the feat of being the first to submit another all-time great in "The Last Stylebender."

• Read More: UFC 305 Results & Highlights: Dricus Du Plessis Submits Israel Adesanya